Investing
Why India’s Richest Man Builds Markets. And Why That’s the Wrong Bet.

He had a choice. He made it.
There's a comparison going around right now that makes people uncomfortable.
America's richest man is building Starlink, Neuralink, SpaceX, Grok, Tesla, and X. Problems that didn't have solutions. Industries that didn't exist. Bets on things most people thought were impossible.
India's richest man is building JioMart, flavoured milk, Campa Cola, and JioHotstar. Grocery delivery. Soft drinks. A streaming service. Things that already existed. Markets that were already there.
One is trying to create things the world has never seen. The other is trying to own everything India already uses.
I've seen people defend this. "India is different." "You have to understand the market." "He's creating jobs." "Distribution is innovation too."
I don't buy it. And I think that defense is exactly why we're stuck.
The Case For Ambani (And Why It's Wrong)
Here's the version of this story that's generous to Ambani.
India is a different kind of market. The fundamentals haven't been solved yet. Most people still don't have reliable grocery delivery. Broadband was expensive before Jio made it cheap. Entertainment was fragmented before JioHotstar. Maybe solving distribution and access at this scale IS the innovation. Maybe it's the foundation that makes everything else possible.
That's a real argument. And it's not entirely wrong.
Jio genuinely changed India. Cheap data at scale unlocked hundreds of millions of people. That's not nothing. I use that infrastructure. You probably do too.
But here's the problem with stopping there.
Jio happened in 2016. It was a genuine disruption. And then what came next? JioMart. Campa Cola. Flavoured milk. The pattern after the one bold bet has been: find what Indians already buy, and make sure they buy it from Reliance.
That's not building. That's acquiring. And there's a difference.
What Ambani Is Actually Doing
Let me say it plainly.
Ambani is not innovating. He is consolidating. And consolidation at his scale is not neutral. It actively makes innovation harder for everyone else.
When one conglomerate owns your phone network, your groceries, your streaming, your retail, your energy, and your fashion, it doesn't just compete with startups. It suffocates them. It sets the terms. It can afford to lose money in any single category indefinitely. No VC-backed startup can compete with that.
The Indian startup ecosystem has real founders building real things. And many of them have watched their category get entered by a Reliance vertical backed by essentially unlimited capital and an existing user base of 400 million people.
That's not competition. That's gravity.
The Cost Nobody Talks About
Here's the number that should bother everyone.
India has 1.4 billion people. We have engineers, mathematicians, scientists, coders. We have IITs producing talent that gets recruited by Google, Meta, and OpenAI. We are not short on intelligence.
And yet. Name one Indian product that is genuinely used at global scale and was built in India. Not a service company. Not outsourcing. A product. Something that changed the world the way Google did, or the iPhone did, or GPS did.
I'll wait.
The honest answer is we don't have one. And when people ask why, the usual answers are: funding environment, regulatory issues, risk aversion, talent drain.
All true. But they miss the most important one.
The people at the top are not modeling what it looks like to take a real swing.
When the most visible, most celebrated, most followed business success story in India is "buy what's already working and scale it," that becomes the template. That becomes what ambitious people try to replicate. That becomes what investors fund. That becomes what business schools teach.
It is not just that Ambani isn't innovating. It's that his model is being copied by everyone watching him.
The Elon Problem (Yes, There Is One)
I want to be honest here. This comparison isn't entirely fair to Ambani or entirely flattering to Musk.
Elon has advantages India doesn't. Deep capital markets. A regulatory environment that, for all its flaws, was designed to allow new industries. A culture that valorizes the founder who tries and fails. A government that, when it wants to, moves fast to enable new sectors. A media that turns ambitious founders into mythology.
India has none of that at the same scale.
So yes, the comparison is asymmetric. Musk is playing a different game on a different field.
But here's what that doesn't excuse.
Ambani is not a first-generation entrepreneur scraping together capital and navigating hostile regulators. He inherited one of the largest conglomerates in the country. He has access to politicians, to capital, to talent, to land, to infrastructure at a scale no founder in India can match.
If anyone in India could afford to take a real swing, it's him.
He chose not to.
What It Would Actually Take
I'm not naive about this. Innovation at the frontier is hard. It fails most of the time. It requires capital that doesn't need returns for ten years. It requires talent that wants to solve hard problems instead of joining a stable conglomerate. It requires a culture that respects the attempt, not just the outcome.
India is not there yet on most of those dimensions.
But the way you get there is not to wait until the conditions are perfect. The way you get there is for the people with the most resources to model the behavior.
One semiconductor company. One serious AI research lab. One moonshot that fails publicly and expensively and teaches the ecosystem something. One bet on a market that doesn't exist yet.
That's all it would take to start shifting what "success" looks like in India.
Instead we got Campa Cola.
Why This Matters For Everyone Building Here
If you're an engineer, a founder, a product person building in India, this conversation is about you.
The ecosystem you're building in is shaped by the models at the top. The capital that's available, the talent that stays versus leaves, the problems people consider worth working on, the kind of ambition that gets celebrated, all of it flows from what the people with the most resources decide to do.
Right now that model is: find a proven market, use scale to dominate it, extract value.
That model produces businesses. It does not produce breakthroughs.
And at some point, probably sooner than most people think, the world is going to be divided into the countries that built the foundational technologies of the next fifty years, and the countries that are users of those technologies.
I don't want India to be a user.
But wanting it and building it are different things. And right now, the person with the most capacity to choose is choosing wrong.
Find me on X.